Case Study · Topaz Reprocessing

PfCRT: From 3.3 Å to 2.9 Å Using the Same Data

We re-picked the public dataset behind the published PfCRT structure, a 49 kDa parasite membrane protein bound to a ~50 kDa Fab, with our Topaz best practices: 5× more particles in the final 2.88 Å map, 9.4× more rare view particles, and clearer side chains. No new microscope time.

Key Results

2.88 Å

Map resolution

3.3 Å published

5×

More particles

84,170 vs. 16,905

9.4×

More rare view particles

18,168 vs. 1,931

3

Side chains re‑fitted

Phe106, Asn167, Lys284

The Challenge

A Small Transporter Behind Malarial Drug Resistance

Mutations in PfCRT help malaria parasites resist drugs by moving chloroquine and piperaquine away from where these drugs normally act. Kim et al. (2019) provided the first structural view of this mechanism. Because PfCRT is small (49 kDa), accurate particle picking is critical for achieving high-resolution cryoEM structures. The published map used 16,905 particles from over one million picks, and some side chains remained ambiguous.

Protein
PfCRT 7G8, the chloroquine-resistance transporter with 10 transmembrane helices
Size
49 kDa
Sample
In lipid nanodiscs, bound to a ~50 kDa Fab
Raw data
EMPIAR-10330 (public)
Published
Kim et al., Nature 2019 · EMD-20806 · PDB 6UKJ

Our Approach

Same Raw Data, Particles Re-Picked with Topaz

We re-picked particles beginning with the raw EMPIAR-10330 movies using the Topaz best practices taught in our Topaz Masterclass, then refined the structure in CryoSPARC.

Residue-Level Evidence

Three Side Chains, Re-Fitted

Choose a residue to compare the published density with ours.

Residue 1 of 3

Phe106

The published density left the ring's position open to interpretation. Ours shows it clearly. So we changed the side chain's rotamer followed by a small local refinement in Coot.

Published vs. Reprocessed

The Numbers, Side by Side

Particle picking

Published (2019)
DoG picker and Gautomatch
Our Reprocessing
Topaz with our Masterclass best practices

Particles in the final map

Published (2019)
16,905
Our Reprocessing
84,170 (5× more)

Rare view particles

Published (2019)
1,931
Our Reprocessing
18,168 (9.4× more)

Resolution, PfCRT with the Fab variable domains (FSC = 0.143)

Published (2019)
3.3 Å (PfCRT at 3.2 Å)
Our Reprocessing
2.88 Å

Refinement

Published (2019)
CryoSPARC non-uniform refinement, with CTF refinement in cisTEM. Nanodisc and Fab constant domain were then subtracted in RELION, followed by a final refinement.
Our Reprocessing
CryoSPARC non-uniform, then local refinement on PfCRT and the Fab variable domains

3.3 Å (the deposited map, EMD-20806) and 2.88 Å are measured over the same region, PfCRT with the Fab variable domains, at the same threshold.

FSC Curves

Local Refinement2.88 Å
Conical FSCs (Local Refinement)2.59 - 3.19 Å

CryoSPARC plots for the final local refinement, with a mask around PfCRT and the Fab variable domains (FSC = 0.143).

Methods & Data

Check Our Work

Built on public data: every published number here is one click away. Open a panel for the full methods and analyses.

MethodsFrom raw movies to the 2.88 Å map

Raw movies from EMPIAR-10330 were motion-corrected with MotionCor3 in RELION, and a Topaz model was trained. The movies were then motion-corrected separately in CryoSPARC, where their CTFs were estimated and all further processing was done. Applying the Topaz best practices taught in our Topaz Masterclass gave 135,692 particles. Non-uniform refinement followed by local refinement with a soft mask around PfCRT and the Fab variable domains gave the final map: 2.88 Å resolution from 84,170 particles (gold-standard FSC0.143). Side-chain rotamers were re-fitted in Coot for Phe106, Asn167, and Lys284, which were ambiguous in the original map.

Orientation CoverageRarest views and viewing directions

We split all viewing directions into 24 equal-area views. The six rarest views account for 1,931 of the published particles and 18,168 of ours: 9.4× as many, from 5× as many particles. Every view grew by at least 2.8×, and these six grew by the most.

Deposited Particles

16,905 particles (published angles)

Our Topaz Particles

84,170 particles

Both plots share the same color scale.

Where the Gain Came FromNumber of particles versus refinement software

We also ran their deposited particles through our own processing and did not get better resolution than the published result. So in this case, the larger number of particles, not newer software, improved the resolution.

Other teams have used the same EMPIAR dataset to test new algorithms, reporting 3.6 Å (CryoSPARC non-uniform refinement; Punjani et al., Nature Methods 2020) and 3.4 Å (RELION Blush regularization; Kimanius et al., Nature Methods 2024). Both reported resolutions are for the whole particle, including the full Fab and the nanodisc, so they cannot be compared directly with the original 3.3 Å result.

Could We Pick Even More Particles?114,378 particles: 2.95 Å

Picking further with our Topaz best practices gave 114,378 particles, which refined to 2.95 Å, slightly short of the 2.88 Å from 84,170 particles, so we report on the 84,170-particle map. We suspect the extra particles are more mobile, or capture a slightly different conformational state of the protein. 3D Classification and 3DFlex on all three particle sets (the deposited 16,905, and our 84,170 and 114,378) gave inconclusive results that could neither confirm nor rule out this hypothesis.

Data & Sources

What Is Your Picking Leaving Behind?

PfCRT is a small membrane protein, about the size of many receptors and transporters in drug discovery. If your map is stuck at a resolution that's too low, or the side chains you care about are still ambiguous, talk to us before you book more microscope time. The answer may already be in your data. We scope and quote every project individually, and you work directly with the founders.

Processed in part using CryoSPARC. CryoSPARC™ and CryoSPARC Live™ are trademarks of Structura Biotechnology Inc. and are used under license.